At least, that's how things went for the back-of-the-hand swatches. When it came time to actually use this on my eye, it was not working out. It looked like I had put on my eyeliner in the morning, got dumped over lunch, after which my dog died: and that was right after I put it on. The tip dragged, the color was patchy, and I couldn't make a clean wing for the life of me.
For $2.50 it's not a huge loss, but it's going to be very difficult for me to find a use for this now.